The Surf Lodge – photo 2 of 5
The Surf Lodge – photo 3 of 5
The Surf Lodge – photo 4 of 5

+1

The Surf Lodge – photo 1 of 5

Rooms

  • Standard Room

    1 King Bed

    Standard Room

  • Junior Studio Suite

    2 Queen Beds

    Junior Studio Suite

Property Overview

The Surf Lodge in Montauk, New York, embodies the effortless charm and free-spirited energy of beachside living. Overlooking Fort Pond, this iconic destination blends bohemian style with coastal luxury, offering chic accommodations, a vibrant social scene, and breathtaking sunsets. Guests can enjoy farm-to-table dining, live music performances, and a laid-back yet refined atmosphere that captures the essence of Montauk’s surf culture. Perfect for both relaxation and adventure, The Surf Lodge is where summer memories are made.

  • On-site boutique featuring curated local and designer goods
  • Weekend DJ sets and creative cocktail programming
  • Restaurant on-site
  • Sunset viewing deck with comfortable lounge seating

Amenities

Features

  • Air conditioning
  • Balcony
  • Separate living room

Bedding and linens

  • Linens provided

Food and drink

  • Kitchen/Kitchenette
  • Restaurant
  • Bar/lounge

Property services

  • Gift shop
  • Smoke-free property

Internet access in public areas

  • Wifi Available

Parking

  • Free self parking

Policies & key facts

Check-in
Check-out
Parking
IncludedFree self parking
Smoking
Smoke-free property

Reviews

3.3

10

Reviews

The Surf Lodge is a popular Montauk venue known for its coastal dining and beach vibe, frequently praised for its service and food quality. However, recent reviews highlight significant issues with parking, high prices, inconsistent food quality, and a somewhat pretentious atmosphere.

  • Coastal dining
  • Fresh seafood
  • Excellent service
  • Healthy food
Location
4 out of 5
Value
2 out of 5
Service
4 out of 5
Amenities
3 out of 5
  1. Emily A

    Rated 4 out of 5

    Pros: beautiful venue, popular hot spot, dining service was immaculate, staff was consistently helpful and kind. Cons: no parking if you’re not a hotel guest. Have to park at the train station that felt 1/4 mile away. Food was average at best! Lobster roll was good with a generous serving of fries, the rigatoni however… was meh. It’s a simple dish and should be a reliable staple on any menu. tasted like tomato paste straight from the can. It appears people would rather be seen here than actually have fun. Barely any dancing or socializing.

  2. Lorraine Olivieri

    Rated 1 out of 5

    Over priced and over -rated ! Weird club vibe- nepo baby clientele and rude staff! Also the parking situation there is a nightmare, we had to park far away and walk down the road, there’s no parking on site!! Very inconvenient!

  3. Lizzy Aaron

    Rated 1 out of 5

    Blatant Robbery. We had a reservation for 7:30 the other night, arrived exactly on time, but the next day were hit with a $150 no show fee. I went back to explain the situation and they apologized profusely, saying they would of course refund me. Weeks later they still hadn't returned the fee and I was told via email that a manager had reviewed the matter and decided they weren't going to refund me after all, but that they hoped I could "dine with them again." The audacity. Also the food was abysmal and the music even worse.

  4. Ceciletravelinfo

    Rated 5 out of 5

    Coastal dining with fresh seafood and breezy beach vibes.

  5. James Rabe

    Rated 1 out of 5

    Smelled like shit

  6. TeamLas3r

    Rated 1 out of 5

    Place is wack. Spend your money elsewhere.

  7. Starling Ramos

    Rated 5 out of 5

  8. Carol Scott

    Rated 5 out of 5

    food was prepared perfectly! excellent tasty and service was a 10! Had the montauk sea bass full of fkavor light and airy!

  9. David Laster

    Rated 5 out of 5

    The absolute best coffee and breakfast spot in montauk. Alex is a world-class barista with consistency. Unlike other options in town. The food is healthy and elevated fresh vegetable-forward cooking.

Map

Montauk

Property Address
183 Edgemere Street
Montauk
Powered byRipe