We were just there for dinner and we used to have such good experiences. We were there many times before just only responding now to a bad third experience the meat we asked for medium rare came medium towards well . Everything is inconsistent , whatever entrée you got one week will be totally different the next week , service is always hit or miss, the wine I can’t believe spectacular location and spent the time on logistics and building wouldn’t have a wine fridge. They serve red wine with such a warm temperature. It’s almost shocking. Again, better restaurants always know red wine is not served at beyond below room temperature.

?????????? 5/5 We stayed at Canoe Place Inn & Cottages for two nights and absolutely loved it. The property is beautiful — elegant, quiet, and full of charm. Our room had a fireplace, which made it feel so cozy and private, especially during the holidays. When we arrived, there was even a Christmas tree in the room — such a thoughtful touch. The service was excellent — warm, professional, and personal. Every staff member we met went out of their way to make us feel welcome. The food at the bar was delicious, and the atmosphere was relaxed but refined. The room was spotless, incredibly quiet, and beautifully designed — you can feel the attention to detail everywhere. The breakfast buffet in the morning was generous, with fresh bagels, eggs, cheese, fruit, and pastries — the perfect start to the day. We were there just after Christmas and right before New Year’s, and the whole place felt festive yet peaceful. It’s a high-end boutique hotel that still feels personal. We can’t wait to come back — it was a wonderful stay from start to finish.

Went for happy hour. Drinks & happy hour dishes were $10-$12 each. Pizza & Caesar salad very good. Breaded clams were average. Surroundings & staff...perfection..can't wait to go again.

We had a wonderful stay at Canoe Place Inn. It’s a gorgeous property in Hampton Bays, easily accessible to several Hamptons towns. The Inn is beautiful and serene. Our room was gorgeous with a terrace and lovely finishings. Despite the Inn being just stunning, it doesn’t have the snobby feel of some of the other Hamptons hotels. I attribute that to the stellar staff who went out of their way to make us feel comfortable. They gave us a full beach set up including pass to explore some great local beaches. And we had a great time hanging out by the pool. The one critique I’d mention is that we were virtually ignored by outdoor wait staff at the pool, while we watching another group getting full service.

Canoe Place Inn & Cottages is easily one of the most memorable places I’ve ever stayed. From the moment I arrived, I felt welcomed and relaxed. The property perfectly blends historic charm with modern comfort, creating a setting that is both elegant and inviting. My room was spotless, beautifully decorated, and filled with thoughtful touches that made it feel like home. Mornings were spent enjoying coffee with a peaceful garden view, and evenings were perfect for a cocktail by the water or unwinding by the fire. The on-site restaurant was a highlight, offering fresh, locally inspired dishes and exceptional service. What truly sets Canoe Place apart is the atmosphere. Every corner feels serene and special, whether you’re exploring the grounds, relaxing in your room, or enjoying the dining experience. The staff go out of their way to make your stay unforgettable, and it shows in every detail. If you’re looking for a getaway in the Hamptons that combines history, comfort, and a warm, welcoming vibe, Canoe Place Inn & Cottages is the perfect choice. I can’t wait to return.

This place feels so grifty and the event planning was less than desirable. Went to a Rufus concert and had tickets to the before-show dinner which was held in a very small space in the back. We were told dinner would be served and then it was burgers and hotdogs you had to pay for, drinks were insanely expensive, and don't even get me started about how disorganized the grilling process was. I don't blame the cooking staff at all but whoever organized that event clearly didn't care about getting people their food in a timely fashion. I ordered food and it took nearly a half hour to get it. It felt like it was all just trying to be a cash grab. No regard for the customer experience. I will never come back. Oh and all the burgers and buns were burned because they didn't plan well. Depressing.

Went to a concert here and it was a nice, intimate venue. The bar selection was scarce and they only had one vodka- an unknown brand. They were a bit disorganized with distributing the bracelets to delineate your section. The restaurant looked good and I’d like to return to try it. The renovation was lovely.

This hotel is great. Supremely convenient location. The room quality is outstanding. The attention to detail from a cleanliness and construction quality perspective is the best I’ve seen. All the staff was so nice and thoughtful, remembered our names and comments, impressive. Josh at the restaurant is a great manager. He even stepped up when the restaurant was busy and helped out his staff on table service. Great leadership and management from him, he deserves a raise. The pool is the perfect temperature. The beet salad was simply delicious. Overall, a truly lovely experience. I’ll be back !!