I had a wonderful weekend in the Hamptons with my daughter to celebrate her 16th birthday and we very much enjoyed our stay at 434 on Main. The breakfasts were absolutely delicious, our room was spacious and comfortable and the renovated bathroom was lovely. Victor and Dan welcomed us into their "home away from home". They even put a birthday candle in my daughter's muffin the morning of her birthday. I highly recommend staying at 434 on Main if you are visiting the area!

This bed and breakfast is truly a little piece of paradise. The owners and the gentleman who oversee the property were incredibly kind and accommodating. My room was spacious, quiet, and very comfortable, with all the amenities I could need. From the moment I inquired about the property until the day I left, communication was thoughtful and reassuring. I highly recommend 434 on Main to anyone looking for a relaxing and welcoming stay. I will most definitely return when traveling to the area. Thank you!

I proposed to my partner while staying at 434 on Main and we had the absolute loveliest time. The accommodations were ideal, the hosts Cam and Victor were so gracious and take what they do very seriously, and breakfast was out of this world. We love the beach at Amagansett and staying at 434 on Main enabled us the ability to go to our favorite beach all day every day - providing us with beach passes, towels, chairs, umbrellas, etc. Not to mention the property is walkable to all the main Amagansett shops and restaurants. Would definitely recommend and plan to stay again!

434 On Main was the absolute perfect spot to stay in Amagansett for a sisters trip! Ideal location and B&B! I arrived early on Friday morning and needed to work during the day. Victor and Cam were very accommodating and made sure I had everything I needed to work from the dining room table while the room was getting ready to check in. It was the perfect spot to work from after just having taken an early morning bus from the city AND to make it even better, I was able to check in much earlier than expected. The room was absolutely perfect, and the bathroom was huge and had everything we needed. The products also smelled amazing, so much so that I got home and ordered them online for myself and my sister. Breakfast each morning was absolutely delicious. Victor and Cam made sure to work with our dietary restrictions and that we were ready to embark on the day with a nutritious and delicious meal. I highly recommend staying here and will definitely be staying here again next time we're in Amagansett!

Couldn’t have asked for a better weekend stay in the Hamptons. The room was spotless and clean, breakfast was amazing, and the location makes traveling around without a car a breeze. What really stood out was Dan and Victor’s hospitality and kindness toward us and our dog, we are so thankful to have found a home away from home that we can see ourselves going back to for years to come!

We had a relaxing visit in this charming inn hosted by the very gracious owners who clearly love what they do. The amenities were thoughtful and the housekeeping immaculate. Breakfasts were delicious, creative and plentiful! Homemade sweets and fresh fruits accompanied frittatas and waffles. The best place to stay in Amagansett!

My husband and I decided on a last-minute Valentine’s Day weekend in the Hamptons and needed a dog-friendly place to stay. We couldn’t have found a more perfect spot! From check-in to check-out, our experience was nothing short of wonderful—relaxing, cozy, and exactly what we needed. Victor and Cam are exceptional hosts who clearly put so much care into their home and guest experience. From the thoughtful little details—fresh cookies, dog treats and toys, snacks, and wine—to the warm and gracious energy they exude, we felt truly welcome from the moment we arrived. Cam is an incredible baker, and we were lucky enough to enjoy some of her delicious treats, along with the homemade breakfasts they prepared each morning. Everything, from the fresh fruit to the perfectly cooked soufflés, was fantastic. The location is ideal—close to everything and even within walking distance of great restaurants and bars. But what truly sets this place apart is the hospitality. They made us (and our dogs!) feel like family, and we can’t wait to come back. This bed and breakfast is absolute gem.