Bay Shore Inn exudes classic elegance and coastal sophistication on Long Island. Its inviting ambiance and thoughtfully designed spaces create a refined and tranquil retreat for travelers. Each detail reflects a commitment to style and comfort, offering a serene and luxurious experience. Perfect for those seeking a peaceful getaway, the inn embodies the charm and grace of its scenic surroundings. Free WiFi Private bathroom 24-hour front desk
Bay Shore Inn offers Free WiFi, 24-hour front desk, Wake-up service, Free toiletries, Air conditioning, Bathtub or shower, Heating, Private bathroom, Cable TV service, Phone, Television, Wifi Available.
Bay Shore Inn is located at 300 Bay Shore Road , Bay Shore.
Bay Shore Inn has an average rating of 2.6 out of 5 based on 480 guest reviews.
Assorted
Standard Room





Bay Shore Inn exudes classic elegance and coastal sophistication on Long Island. Its inviting ambiance and thoughtfully designed spaces create a refined and tranquil retreat for travelers. Each detail reflects a commitment to style and comfort, offering a serene and luxurious experience. Perfect for those seeking a peaceful getaway, the inn embodies the charm and grace of its scenic surroundings.
The Bay Shore Inn receives extremely mixed reviews, with significant concerns regarding bedbugs, aggressive staff behavior, and severe disrepair. While a few guests praised affordability and friendly staff, the overwhelming majority reported negative experiences including infestations, damaged property, and mistreatment.
I literally just paid for 3 nights, I woke up with bedbug bites all over me. I’m currently waiting for the local Police to arrive so I can document that the hotel is refusing to give me a refund.
BEST HONEYMOON DESTINATION!! Me and my new husband Stan Michael Laurent went after celebrating our wedding in Mexico and we wouldn’t want to go anywhere else ?? The picture below was the hallway i walked into and then the hotel set up the bed after googling us to find our wedding registry. The patio outside was extremely nice with a beautiful view of suffolk county. Do NOT judge a book by its cover. I was DEVESTATED to leave and will be returning for my anniversary of birth on April 20th (pot day). Me and my husband loved the room service. Food and cigars were top tier. I love you, Stan, because you make my life feel safe, steady, and full all at once. You are my calm in the chaos and my laughter on the hard days, the person who knows me better than anyone and still chooses me every single day. I love the way you show up—not just in the big moments, but in the quiet, ordinary ones that end up meaning the most. The way you listen, the way you care, the way you try even when things aren’t easy reminds me how lucky I am to call you my husband. You make me feel seen, supported, and deeply loved, and with you I feel like I can be completely myself without fear or doubt. Loving you feels natural, effortless, and right, and I’m endlessly grateful for the life we share, the memories we’ve made, and the future we’re building together. Anyways, when i have children, they will be brought into this wonderful world in room 101 (where we stayed). All in all, trust me and go to the bay shore inn ??????????????????????? With love, Betsy M. Laurent
They will set you up in a room and have police purposely incriminate you. Forcefully Rip you from your vehicle with no probable cause and waste your rime. Better to steer clear from here and enjoy your time elsewhere if you don’t want your night to end up like shit.
Most disgusting place I have ever seen. Broken furniture, mirrors on the walls were either missing or broken, mold, dirty bedding with burns. Sign said no refunds, this place should come with a warning label. For the price you pay it might be better to just keep moving on.... If I could give it a negative review, I would
The price was the cheapest out of 7 hotels I checked in a 10 mile radius, and there was a clean bed and nice and warm in the room as there is snow outside and hot water for the shower my stay with my husband was great.
The staff is quite friendly and courteous and is understanding when it comes to checking out of the place. The maintenance guy was especially a ton of help when it came to fixing a few things around my room. I can't comment on the smell of the place as I still am recovering from Covid.
Never judge a book it’s cover! The outside looks horrible and we almost left. We got a room for short stay and the room was surprisingly nice. It was clean and so was the bathroom. Heat worked well. Front desk person was fine and very nice. Parking was fine and discreet. Rates reasonable. If you are a looking to go somewhere to play for a few hours I would consider this place. I post this as I was looking at reviews myself before we went _ hope this helps.
This property is not bookable on our official site, you will be taken to the listing externally.