Amazing experience at the beachcomber! Room was nice, everything was easily accessible. The pool was heated, there’s beach access right across the street. Everything in town is in close driving distance. And most importantly they had friendly staff. Our stay was amazing!

We have been coming to Montauk for 10 years but stayed at a different location. From now and on we will be coming here. Their swimming pool is amazing! It's clean, deep and the water is really warm. And you can see the ocean from the pool!

Had an amazing stay at the Beachcomber Resort Everything was spotless, comfortable, and well taken care of, but what really made the stay extra special was Judy. She went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect and made us feel so welcomed. We stayed in 413 this summer. It was a 10/10 experience and will definitely be coming back :)

I was very disappointed when I got to the resort. The pictures I saw our prior to arrival told a way different story than what I saw. My room was dated, small, and the couch stink like armpits. For the money I paid I expected a little better quality. The bathtub was also disgusting. Water pressure is terrible, And the pool was way smaller than expected. That will be my last time ever staying at this resort. Very disappointed in the quality.

If you just dont know any better, this place is for you. The place is run down, very dated and on top of that my room was a disgrace when I got there. Rusted refrigerator and the list can go on. Not worth my time adding any more. Just a cheap Motel with high end prices.

Location is great! Walking distance to town. Beach is more private because of the location. Very nice heated pool.

We return to Room 431 every summer, and it never fails to be the perfect setting for our family getaway. The highlight is without a doubt the panoramic ocean view—we’ve been lucky enough to spot humpback whales and dolphins right from the balcony, an experience that never gets old. The room itself is spacious and inviting, with a new king-sized bed that feels like sleeping on a cloud. Our kids love the sofa bed with a memory foam mattress, which is just as comfortable as a regular bed. The property’s amenities make our stays even better. There’s a pool for relaxing afternoons, a sauna and gym for unwinding or staying active, and best of all, a private beach just a short walk down a quiet path. It always feels secluded and peaceful, far from the crowds of the busier public beaches. Overall, Room 431 strikes the perfect balance of comfort, convenience, and breathtaking views. It’s a spot we look forward to returning to year after year, and we highly recommend it for both couples and families.

The resort was wonderful!!! Beautiful views, beautiful rooms, friendly staff, pool was relaxing, enjoyable and great temperature. There is an exceptional private ?? beach that our group loved!!! I highly recommend.

Had a great experience at The Beachcomber!! We stayed in the hill house suite and everything was very clean and the cleaning people came every day. The pool was so clean as well as the rest of the facilities. All the staff were so nice. Only thing was that some stuff was a little dated like the TVs and the couch/creaky pull out couch, but overall everything was great and I’ll definitely be back!

Stayed here for a wedding over the weekend. What a great place! Plenty of room for 4 people. A 13 minute walk to town and great views of the ocean. Will definitely come back and stay longer!!