I had a great stay here - the room was clean, and the bed was super comfortable for a great night's sleep. But what truly sets this place apart is the outstanding hospitality. Every staff member goes completely out of their way to assist, and I especially want to give a huge shoutout to Karen! Her warmth, helpfulness, and local recommendations made my stay so convenient. You can tell they genuinely care about their guests here. Can’t wait to come back!

We just had a wonderful trip to the Hamptons and the Sag Harbor Inn was a fantastic host. We came in late and they gave us an end room facing the beautiful harbor and bay. All of the staff were super courteous to the guests, and it's a welcome feeling. The location adjacent to busy and hip Sag Harbor main street is close, yet far enough away to enjoy peace and quiet. Thank you to the hotel for a wonderful stay!

My bed here was extremely dirty. When I turned down the sheets, I was greeted with an excess of crumbs and dirt (see photos). Large grains of dirt or sand. I only stayed one night so must have been left over. I don't know how this was missed. It was very late at night so not a good time to switch rooms. For the most important part of a hotel (the place where you sleep), this is a massive blunder. Sucks because it's a nice place! Nice service, nice pool. Included breakfast is quite small and covers the essentials (minus hot food). Please address the cleaning issue.

BAD HOTEL. ANYONE WITH CLASS KNOWS these people are rude, they have horrible service, are disrespectful to guests, and provide horrible treatment of guests. Also, they suck. No one cool would stay here.

Sag Harbor Inn is a waterfront hotel located right in the heart of Sag Harbor, one of the most charming and historic villages in the Hamptons. It has a classic, slightly traditional hotel style, but what makes it stand out is its location directly on the harbor with beautiful water views. The overall vibe is relaxed and nautical, more focused on comfort and scenery than modern luxury design. It feels like a solid, dependable place to stay if you want to be in the center of town with easy access to everything.

The biggest plus of this place is the immaculate cleanliness and its walking distance to town. The breakfast in the morning features bagels, yogurt, coffee. You can sit by the table facing the bay. Very cute.

This hotel is clean, well located, and you get a great breakfast included in the price of your room. There is a nice pool and sitting area… I really enjoyed my stay here. The staff keeps the place immaculate and the FRONT DESK team is just lovely.

I love the Sag Harbor Inn. Spacious bright rooms with big window and glass door to porch. One side of the hotel faces the pool and the other side faces the harbor. Very relaxed atmosphere, down to earth, with warm polite staff. Everything is very well maintained.

After a harrowing (and I do mean harrowing) ordeal with hotels.com trying to extend a reservation, Ean of the front desk took care of everything. Truly, a delightful conversation and quick fix for an issue that I'd already spent several hours trying to remedy. The Inn is lucky to have him on staff.

This place was so clean. Would recommend it to anyone. We will be back. Great water views. Bountiful parking. Continental breakfast with coffee, bagels, yogurt, cereal & fruit. Place is so relaxing and quiet. Easy walk to town. Staff was excellent.