About Milford T. Benjamin House B&B

The Milford T. Benjamin House B&B offers a warm, historic retreat set along Jamesport’s scenic Main Road in the heart of North Fork wine country. This charming bed-and-breakfast blends 19th-century character with modern comforts, creating an inviting atmosphere for couples, solo travelers, and weekend explorers. Guests can unwind on peaceful grounds, enjoy personalized hospitality, and take advantage of its close proximity to renowned vineyards, farm stands, and beaches. Restored historic home featuring original architectural details Cozy common areas ideal for relaxing or reading Walking distance to nearby wineries and tasting rooms Peaceful outdoor spaces with garden seating Intimate atmosphere ideal for romantic or quiet getaways

Amenities at Milford T. Benjamin House B&B

Milford T. Benjamin House B&B offers Wifi Available, Premium bedding, Patio, Private bathroom, Television.

Location

Milford T. Benjamin House B&B is located at 1216 Main Rd, NY-25, Jamesport.

Reviews and ratings

Milford T. Benjamin House B&B has an average rating of 3.9 out of 5 based on 297 guest reviews.

Rooms and accommodations at Milford T. Benjamin House B&B

  • Standard Room

    Assorted Bedding

    Standard Room

  • business logo
    mm
    /
    dd
    /
    yyyy
    -
    mm
    /
    dd
    /
    yyyy
Image of Milford T. Benjamin House B&B
Image of Milford T. Benjamin House B&B
Image of Milford T. Benjamin House B&B
Image of Milford T. Benjamin House B&BImage of Milford T. Benjamin House B&B

Property Overview

The Milford T. Benjamin House B&B offers a warm, historic retreat set along Jamesport’s scenic Main Road in the heart of North Fork wine country. This charming bed-and-breakfast blends 19th-century character with modern comforts, creating an inviting atmosphere for couples, solo travelers, and weekend explorers. Guests can unwind on peaceful grounds, enjoy personalized hospitality, and take advantage of its close proximity to renowned vineyards, farm stands, and beaches.

  • Restored historic home featuring original architectural details
  • Cozy common areas ideal for relaxing or reading
  • Walking distance to nearby wineries and tasting rooms
  • Peaceful outdoor spaces with garden seating
  • Intimate atmosphere ideal for romantic or quiet getaways

Amenities

Internet access in public areas

  • Wifi Available

Bedding and linens

  • Premium bedding

Features

  • Patio
  • Private bathroom

Media and electronics

  • Television

Reviews

3.9
297
Reviews

Milford T. Benjamin House B&B offers a delightful experience centered around its exceptional winery and restaurant, Jamesport Vineyards. Guests consistently praise the delicious food, particularly the wood-fired pizzas and fresh ingredients, along with the beautiful grounds and attentive staff. While some have noted minor service inconsistencies, the overall atmosphere is warm and inviting.

Delicious FoodBeautiful GroundsAttentive StaffWood-Fired PizzaWine Selection
cleanliness4.5
location4.5
value4
service4
amenities4.5
A
Albert Milite
7 months ago

My FAVORITE winery! Not only is the wine amazing but the restaurant on premises- WOW! Amazing pizza and other Italian favorites! A must try! You’ll be hooked!

M
Mia Bedford
9 months ago

We arrived at 1:30 with no reservations and we didn’t wait long. There was ample parking. I even saw an EV charger, but I wasn’t sure if it was for the owners or for visitors. The pizza was very good. Our waiter was super kind and attentive. We accidentally left without our leftovers and realized half a mile down the road. We turned around and ran back in. The waiter had saved our food for us! We walked around the grounds a little and found ample seating

B
Barsnobs
10 months ago

We had a really great experience at Jamesport Vineyards. Delicious pizza, I mean delicious. Fresh ingredients, crispy and flavorful. The wine was outstanding and the Caesar salad was fresh, peppery and parmesan-y. Very good. The grounds are beautiful and the music was great. Staff was friendly and it was very clean. I would love to go back. Highly recommend. Tell em Barsnobs sent ya!

C
Carlo M.
almost 2 years ago

I was given notice the day before our visit that we were having a “Family” Day and would have lunch on the patio here. My first thought was, Oh great (forcing a smile), lunch on a patio in 90 degree heat and humidity…… I loved it from the minute we walked through the front door. Warmly greeted at the door and led through the indoor wine bar and tables that had a nostalgic, old timey feel, to the back patio where our table was. Although it was a hot, humid July summer day there was a nice little breeze that swept across the patio. When it stopped, we asked if the ceiling fans to be put on and without hesitation our waiter accommodated the request. We started with a Red wine flight, oven warmed olives and ricotta with apple appetizers. Both apps were fantastic. My wife and daughter each got their own wood fired pizza, I opted for the Charred Octopus. Nothing but good things to say about all 3 meals (I sampled each pizza). Food was excellent. Now to the back area which is impressive by itself. Off the patio there was plenty of shaded areas to sit, eat, drink and be merry. The yard is beautifully landscaped with lots of flower boxes and trees, they even have a Bocce Ball court. Plenty of great scenery to get loads of great pictures. We all had a nice experience here and would surely recommend this to anyone who enjoys the outdoor dining scene or a “Family” day trip on the North Fork. I know we will be returning for sure.

B
Basil Puglisi (basilpuglisi)
almost 4 years ago

This is a wonderful experience, the food is amazing, literally one of the best wood fired pizza experiences ever, the meatballs are out of this world!!! Now the wine was impressive for the whites only surpassed by their dessert wine which was worth stocking up before we left. The seating in the area for waited tables is by far inferior to the general public area, the staff was really the hidden gem here, from the hostesses, especially Rose to the food team you really are treated like a guest in someones home. Bravo to the Jamesport Vinyards team, this is a wonderful experience all around.

M
Mario Moquete
almost 5 years ago

Nice winery. Some of the staff are friendly (our waitress was, but not the hostess who made us wait more than 10 min and then came saying "our hours are very strictly and you are 3 min late from 6pm our cutoff for tasting, so we can take you for some wine but tasting is out of question ???). Waitress was nice enough to offer some tasting anyhow. Wines are of good quality. Their backyard is nicely landscaped.

Map

Property Address
1216 Main Rd, NY-25
Jamesport
Property Contact
631-722-5256

Milford T. Benjamin House B&B

NORTH FORK
Bed & Breakfast
3.9
297 reviews

Assorted Bedding


This property is not bookable on our official site, you will be taken to the listing externally.