Ruschmeyer’s Inn offers a relaxed, bohemian retreat in the heart of Montauk, surrounded by lush woodlands and just minutes from the beach. Known for its camp-inspired vibe, the property blends rustic charm with modern comforts, creating an inviting escape for couples, friends, and groups. Guests can enjoy lively social spaces, serene outdoor areas, and easy access to Montauk’s vibrant dining and nightlife scene. With its unique character and natural setting, Ruschmeyer’s delivers a memorable stay on the East End. On-site restaurant and bar with a lively social atmosphere Close to Montauk’s beaches, shopping, and dining Laid-back, camp-style ambiance throughout the property Ideal for groups, celebrations, and retreats
Ruschmeyer's Inn offers Bar/lounge, Restaurant, Wifi Available, Linens provided, Air conditioning, AM/FM alarm clock radio, Coffeemaker, Mini-fridge, Television, Families welcome.
Ruschmeyer's Inn is located at 161 Second House Rd, Montauk.
Ruschmeyer's Inn has an average rating of 3.4 out of 5 based on 267 guest reviews.
1 King Bed
Standard Room, 1 King Bed
1 Queen Bed
Deluxe Room, 1 Queen Bed
2 Queen Beds
Deluxe Room, 2 Queen Beds
1 Queen Bed
Standard Room, 1 Queen Bed
1 King Bed
Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed
1 King Bed, 1 Twin Bed and 1 Twin Bunk Bed
Suite




+8

Ruschmeyer’s Inn offers a relaxed, bohemian retreat in the heart of Montauk, surrounded by lush woodlands and just minutes from the beach. Known for its camp-inspired vibe, the property blends rustic charm with modern comforts, creating an inviting escape for couples, friends, and groups. Guests can enjoy lively social spaces, serene outdoor areas, and easy access to Montauk’s vibrant dining and nightlife scene. With its unique character and natural setting, Ruschmeyer’s delivers a memorable stay on the East End.
Ruschmeyer's Inn offers a scenic location with appealing amenities like outdoor patios and campfires, praised by guests for its convenient access to town and beaches. However, recent reviews highlight inconsistent service and lengthy wait times for food, suggesting areas for improvement.
Review for restaurant only. We waited over 1.5 hours for our food! Our appetizers came out quickly but our entrees took forever. We finally called the manager over to let them know we were still waiting. He checked with the kitchen and assured us only 5 more minutes. It took 30 minutes before we complained again and told them we were about to leave. Our food then magically arrived. For the price tag the food didn't measure up, even putting aside the delay. It is also extremely loud, even before the DJ started up. It's a beautiful restaurant but does not bring what a restaurant should bring: good food and good service.
The rooms provided good value for the cost. Felt a little like a "Dirty Dancing" set with frills. The staff behind the bar (when we were allowed there " were great but we received absolutely no communication from Management that there was a "Private Party" Thursday, Friday and Saturday and that the hotel bar was "Out of Bounds" in the evenings for hotel guests. The Management/Owners were onsite but appeared to be wrapped up in their own world with no interaction or PR with guests even in mid-late afternoons. The dismissive approach when asking if we can have a drink at the bar left an unsavory tone to our stay .... no mention of apologies for the inconvenience or "Please take a seat - we are so sorry - what can we get you on the house for the inconvenience". Drunk "gospel guests" out on the lawn at the early hours of the morning was unreasonable. Again, staff were great - management and any thought to how paying guests might feel by management was absent ! Ask before booking.
If you're searching for a hotel or motel with a cozy and relaxing atmosphere, your search ends here. The room provided everything we needed for a perfect getaway. I particularly loved the Byredo products in the restroom, adding a touch of luxury. The staff were exceptionally kind and helpful; they even surprised me with a bottle of rosé for my birthday! The cherry on top was the availability of free bikes for us to explore the area. My husband and I will definitely be returning!
Firstly, the staff were very friendly and informative. They had a nice welcome note in the room which described the amenities. The hotel is also located in a very convenient spot between where we were headed (ferry) and downtown. The rooms were very nice and well-maintained. They had water and popcorn which was a nice touch. The coolest thing about the rooms is the door code to get in - meaning no key - which was super convenient. In saying that, the bathroom layout was on the smaller side — the door didn’t fully open or close without a big effort (and noise) which was very inconvenient- squeezing in and out. Outside the rooms, the property was beautiful, and the outdoor patio area was a great spot to relax. They gave 2 free drink coupons which we used and sat in the very comfortable outdoor area - that had fire pits and couches and lots of seating. It was very serene. The service was okay, but there were a few glitches that led to disappointments. We were really looking forward to the free s’mores kit they some of when checking in, but when we asked that evening, we were told they had no firewood and didn’t have the proper items to provide the kit. Additionally, the complimentary breakfast was very underwhelming. They’d probably be better off dropping that as an amenity. Overall, we really did enjoy our stay, but a few simple improvements in service and amenities would make a big difference.
I had the best time here. The food is great, and the shared amenities were awesome. Each cabin has its own outdoor patio, and then a shared public space with games and campfires every night. Its a convenient location and you can walk to town and beaches really easily. The hosts were incredible! 10/10 for all the staff!
We had a fantastic stay at this hotel! Our room was clean, comfortable, and well-equipped with everything we needed. What really made our experience special was the amazing service. Kat, the General Manager, was incredibly welcoming and attentive. She made sure we felt right at home and went above and beyond to make our stay enjoyable. We truly appreciated her kindness and professionalism. We’ll definitely be back!
This property is not bookable on our official site, you will be taken to the listing externally.