We had a great stay at J&S Cottages and would definitely recommend it to anyone visiting the Southold area. The cottage was clean, comfortable, and had everything we needed. The location was perfect—quiet and relaxing, but still close to the wineries, restaurants, shops, and everything else the North Fork has to offer. The property is absolutely beautiful, they have plenty of things to do on the water that’s right outside the cottages. The owners Sandy & John were welcoming, responsive, and made the entire stay easy from start to finish. It was the perfect place for a relaxing getaway, and we would absolutely stay here again.

Had the pleasure of staying here last night and it truly is a treasure. Sandy and John are the sweetest and most accommodating people. The cottages were so clean and the view was incredible. I will 100% be coming back to stay.

We’ve had the pleasure of staying at these cottages several times, and every visit has been just as special as the last. The peaceful atmosphere, beautiful surroundings, and sense of serenity make it incredibly difficult to leave. Whether you’re fishing off the docks, relaxing with a good book, or simply taking a walk around the property to enjoy the gorgeous flowers and scenery, there’s something here for everyone. It’s the perfect place to slow down, unwind, and appreciate nature. More than anything, these cottages have become a true home away from home for our family. Every stay gives us the opportunity to reconnect, spend quality time together, and create memories we’ll always cherish. We can’t recommend this place highly enough, and we’re already looking forward to our next visit.

10/10 experience at J & S Reeve Cottages. This hidden gem is in the perfect location for a serene getaway right on the water, close to local farm stands, wineries, etc.! I stayed here in October and it was absolutely stunning with the fall foliage. You can even go to the family farm stand up the road to get some local produce and cook some dinner right on the property. It is the cutest, clean coastal chic cottage and my favorite part is the screened in porch. I love how they have kayaks on property for guest to use too! Sandy and John are some of the best people I’ve ever met and are so welcoming and accommodating - they really make you feel at home. Can’t wait to come back here soon!

A family friend invited us to share in this special place for her. It did not dissapoint. The cottage was charming and well maintained. The grounds.... perfect 10 out of 10 - absolutely amazing. The view over the water is peaceful and serene with relaxing nature sounds abounding. We didn't avail ourselves of the picnic tables, outdoor chairs or Weber BBQ grills, but they were very inviting. Sandy and John are gracious hosts. I highly recommend this spot.

The Reeves cottages are Perfect in every way Five stars are not enough . Blessed to have found this heavenly place . Thank you John and Sandy .

J&S Reeve Cottages are fantastic! We rented the three waterfront cottages for several families and had plenty of space. The property is gorgeous and it is incredibly peaceful on the water. The kids loved playing on the grass and running around. Sandy was lovely and accommodated all of our individual needs. We loved it and will be back!

What a fabulous place to stay! The quaint cottages have such a welcoming vibe! The beauty of nature is all around the property ?? Sandy and John are gracious hosts and always available for local information! We will definitely return!

Seemed like it would have been delightful. Booked (with confirmation), gathered our toddler and dog in the car and drove out there from Brooklyn only to learn that they gave our spot away to someone who walked-in w/out a reservation! They issued the cancellation a minute before coming out to talk to us. We were stranded and had to scramble to find a place to stay. I will say it seemed lovely, but I would call and confirm that you in fact *have* the spot you reserved.

Great place to stay!! A hidden gem. If you are looking for a quiet, relaxing retreat, this is it. Our cottage was well equipped, spacious and clean. The screened in porch is the clincher! We enjoyed a beautiful waterfront view while having morning coffee and a glass of wine later in the evening. No hustle, bustle. Just feet up and relax!