I’ve stayed here a couple times and each time it’s great. Betty is wonderful and incredibly helpful. All of the staff I’ve encountered has been very pleasant and friendly. The rooms are clean and welcoming. I believe I was told they were recently renovated as well. It is located in a walkable area with stores like Target and 7/11 nearby.

We were very impressed with our stay at the Whitman Motor Lodge. The room was nicely remodeled, the bed was comfortable, and the bathroom had a beautiful marble floor and a step-down shower. Even though it's on a main road, our room was surprisingly quiet. We’ll definitely be back!

My family and I stay at Whitman Motor Lodge every year for a family gathering. After previous visits, I wasn't sure if I would return, but I'm so glad we did. When making our reservation, my wife spoke with Betty, who informed us that the Whitman Motor Lodge had undergone renovations. Upon our arrival, we were absolutely blown away by the transformation. The appearance of the property, the cleanliness, and the condition of our room exceeded all expectations. It truly puts a whole new meaning to the term "Motor Lodge." I would also like to recognize Betty for providing exceptional customer service. From the moment we made our reservation through the check-in process, she was friendly, professional, welcoming, and made everything smooth and stress-free. Betty is truly an asset to Whitman Motor Lodge and goes above and beyond to make guests feel valued. Thank you, Betty, and the entire Whitman Motor Lodge team for providing such an excellent customer experience. We look forward to returning again next year!

Great quiet rooms and very hospitable staff. AC was a nice uniform noise and heard no highway house. The basics but ideal

This place was a huge surprise. I saw the exterior photos and did indeed judge this property but after my stay I have to say this is one of the nicest little places I have stayed at in a long time. Betty was extremely friendly and helpful. Everyone was very accommodating. We ended up booking this after we were refused an early check in by a larger hotel (which we paid for during reservation online) and they accommodated me and my pregnant partners early check in seamlessly. They didn’t make us feel like another tourist and were very personable. The rooms are very comfortable and clean. This was such a nice break during a very busy time in our lives.

Our check in was easy, Betty was delightful and offered several suggestions regarding restaurants in the area. The room was immaculate and had comfortable bedding. The bathroom had a beautiful marble floor and step down shower. We were in the back of the motor inn and it was very quiet. The location was accessible to everything. A delightful visit!

Stayed here for a couple of nights during the Ryder Cup at Bethpage. The hotel was very clean and the rooms have been recently updated. The room had a king size bed, large tv, minifridge/freezer, and microwave. No coffee maker but they do have coffee in the lobby. If you are looking to spend any extended time in the hotel and want to watch tv, bringing a streaming device might be the best choice since there are very limited options with the tv service that's provided. The front desk staff were very friendly and there were no issues with traffic noise or anything. I would definitely stay here again!

Wonderful facility with the most gracious proprietor. Luxurious rooms, especially the bath and shower. Close to New York City and the North Shore of Long Island. We enjoyed our stay and hope to return! Thank you WML!

Found this place because of Google reviews. It didn't disappoint. The room was amazing and the area was quite. The lady at the front desk was super nice. I will definitely stay there again. 10/10

We had the most wonderful 6-night stay here, and I can’t say enough good things! Just like all the other reviews, it truly was a lovely experience. The interior was spotless and beautifully kept, and every member of the staff was so kind, warm, and accommodating. The front desk was always cheerful and eager to help with anything I needed. We had a fridge and microwave as well. The whole place was peaceful and quiet. I’m so grateful for such a comfortable and welcoming stay. highly recommend, would come back!